Review: D&G Comparing Rose The One with The One

by Karin on May 12, 2011 · 0 comments

in Bergamot et al, Comparing, Dolce and Gabbana, Lychee, Perfume review, Pink grapefruit, Rose, Sandalwood, Vanilla

Rose The One
I was able to try Rose The One in person tonight, and I have to say it is a nice addition to the original The One.

What are the notes?
Rose The One

notes: blackcurrant, pink grapefruit, mandarin, lily of the valley, rose, litchi, peony, Madonna lily, ambrette seed, sandalwood, musk and vanilla.

The One

top: bergamot, mandarin, lychee and peach,
mid: Madonna lily, muguet and jasmine,
base: of plum, vetiver, vanilla, amber and musk.

How do they compare?
The main difference for me is the addition of pink grapefruit in Rose The One. That comes across strongly in the beginning, perhaps even stronger than the rose. But citrus notes burn off fast from the top notes, leaving a gentler, softer version of The One.

Both fragrances begin with almost a fizz, but the fizz is stronger in Rose The One, as you would expect, because of the tart aspect of the grapefruit.

Does it resemble the original The One?
Unlike some flankers that have no resemblance to the original fragrance except for the name, Rose The One stays true to the original concept, while making it more wearable with the addition of the rose and pink grapefruit and softening it.

My Take:
I found over time that The One was a fragrance so distinctive that I tired of it. I couldn't layer up over it to get another fragrance later in the day, which I like to do.

I like citrus in a fragrance. And I have trouble wearing roses. But Rose The One is one I can wear. I'm really happy that it has a lighter feel to it than The One. I prefer it.

Have you tried it?
Do you wear either of them? Which do you prefer?

Karin
www.savvythinker.com

Originally posted 2009-10-26 19:26:44.

Blog Traffic Exchange Related Posts Blog Traffic Exchange Related Websites
  • guidePocket Fragrance Scent Guide Continued This is a pocket fragrance scent guide for women's fine fragrances. There are hundreds of high quality perfumes out there, and knowing a little about...
  • Escada Sentiment perfumeEscada Sentiment Perfume Review This is a review of the Escada Sentiment perfume. Originally introduced by Escada in the year 2000, the Escada Sentiment perfume is a perfume for...
  • Kenzo TokyoKenzo Tokyo Cologne for Men Review The Kenzo Tokyo cologne represents a serene nature amidst a crazy and poetic city, and it rests in the intersection between bamboo and skyscrapers set...
Online Stores

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: